My eBay Finds for September 2025
My eBay finds for September 2025 were about the same from last month. We did get a few sales on Poshmark and 1 sale on Mercari.
Getting those extra sales from the other platforms are certainly a bonus! We use a cross lister – Nifty.ai. Sign up with our link and receive 15% off your first month – use CUSTERKSFINDS – to save!
eBay Finds for September 2025
In September, we sold 17 items on eBay (same as last month) but we also had 1 refund on a clothing item – a Quacker Factory Shirt. They loved the shirt but it didn’t fit. I told them to donate it as we held it for a long time with no interest.
The first 3 items of the month, we sold a 2017 Pokemon Tank Top Size XL; a Unity World Wear Blouse size Medium; and Angels Everluxe Shape Skinny Black Denim jeans. The Pokemon Tank Top was bought at a thrift store. The Unity World and Angels jeans came from garage sales.
The next 3 sales were Red Dead Redemption Game of the Year Xbox One / Xbox 360; the Ultimate Crayon Collection with Sharpener; and the Legend of Korra complete Series New in Package. The xBox game came from an estate auction. The Ultimate Crayon collection and Legend of Korra came from a storage auction.
The next 3 sales were Black Nocona belt with decorative buckle; 2008 Pout Pout Fish plush; and an Angels 360 Scult Skinny Blue Denim jeans. The belt sold for $25; I believe it came from an estate auction. The pout pout fish plush came from a storage unit. The Angels jeans came from a garage sale at a senior center.
The next 3 sales were a Joey Lauren Adams autograph; Becky Lynch The Man Homage Shirt; and Little House on the Prairie Season 3 bluray. The Becky Lynch shirt was bought at the thrift store and the bluray came from our house.
On September 21st, we sold 2 more items – Hustle Bear No Cap White Shirt Size 3XL and an Ashley Princess Watch Bands only set of 24. Both of these items came from a storage unit.
To finish out the month of sales on eBay, we sold 2 more items. 1984 Dakin Removable Shell turtle plush – this was found in a plush lot and it was in poor condition. Also, we sold The Parent Trap Double Trouble Edition DVD, which came from a storage unit.
On Poshmark, we sold 6 items, totalling a rough net profit of $32. Most items sold under the $10 mark but luckily, I didn’t have too much into the items.
The first 3 items sold were a Marvel Groot with magnetic plush; JFK and family, Jacqueline Onassis paper dolls; and Farmers’ Market Day by Shanda trent book. The Marvel Groot came from the thrift store. The paper dolls came from one of first storage units; very happy that sold! The Farmers’ Market book came from a recent storage unit.
The last 3 items sold were a faded red Pirana Joe Jamaica Hat; and 2 pairs of Faded Glory Stretch Size 16W jeans. The Faded Glory jeans sold as a bundle and were from a storage unit. The Pirana Joe hat came from a garage sale.
On Mercari, we sold only 1 item – LA Rams OTS shirt. This came from my FIL, who used to love the Rams. He’s got dementia now and doesn’t remember anything about the sport.
The sales for October nearly doubled from last month, which is awesome! Stay tuned for the next blog post.
